I have used both Mackie control pro and Behringer X-touch in Mackie emulation with great success.
I actually prefer the X-touch somewhat but there is a problem with it if the cpu of your computer is an AMD type.
My laptop and one of my tower are AMD and it does not work! The other older tower and laptop use Intel chips and works like a charm.
It's not a question of drivers! Even Behringer are baffled by this one!
The real Mackie (Mc Coy
) works with no problem at all on every machine.
I also have two small controller that I use on a field recorder (Audio Devices MixPre 10 ll) a Akai MidiMix and a small Korg nanoKontrol2 that I intend to try on my multitrack system, I need just the 'tape' control buttons... start, stop, recored rewind fast forward etc... I don't have much use for the sliders in this case.
(Edit concerning the problem with AMD cpu chip set)
There is thread on a forum
here that seems to have solved the problem.
I have to get deeper into this as I really would like to have the X-touch running!